In this clip from “Giant Mess”, New York Mets fan Neal Lynch takes a look ahead at the potential 2024 roster.

0-man roster analysis for 2024:
Francisco Lindor, SS:
first 30-30 season.
one of the game’s best shortstops
contract runs through 2031 at an annual average value of $34.1 million

Brandon Nimmo, CF:
re-signed for eight years and $162 million
played a career-best 152 games
career-best 24 home runs
should provide dependability

Pete Alonso, 1B
final year of arbitration.
$14.5 million for Alonso last winter was a record for a first baseman in his second time through the process.
29-year-old becomes eligible for free agency after 2024 season.

Edwin Díaz, RHP
baseball’s most expensive reliever,

Kodai Senga, RHP:
Rookie of the Year candidate
Cy Young Award
five-year deal out of Japan, but he can opt out after 2025 if he logs at least 234 innings over the next two seasons.

Jeff McNeil, UT:
extended him before the 2023 season

Francisco Alvarez, C

Starling Marte, OF:
third year of a four-year contract worth $78 million.
Mets’ second-highest paid player
produced just a .625 OPS in 86 games in 2023
34-year-old
groin surgery and other ailments

José Quintana, LHP:
A consistent performer,
bone graft surgery on his rib,
missed the first half
enters final year of contract at $13 million

Brooks Raley, LHP
said he’d like the Mets to pick up the team option they have on him ($6.5 million)
solid high-leverage reliever who can also get right-handed batters out.

Adam Ottavino, RHP:
native New Yorker
holds a player option worth $6.75 million, which is $1 million less than he made in 2023.
remained respectable
should be considered a high-leverage option

David Peterson, LHP:
had a 8.08 ERA through mid-May at a time when the Mets seriously needed him,
28, as a starter, but also flashed some intrigue in bullpen.
arbitration-eligible for the first time.

Tylor Megill, RHP
strong finish within a disappointing year
28, remains a year away from arbitration
has minor-league options remaining

Drew Smith, RHP
higher walk rate
mostly league-average numbers
has minor-league options remaining
won’t be a free agent until 2025

Trevor Gott, RHP
arbitration-eligible

Omar Narváez, C
holds a player option for $7 million

Brett Baty, 3B:
In 389 plate appearances,.598 OPS
struggled in the field

Mark Vientos, 3B/1B/DH
In September, hit six home runs with a .739 OPS in 93 plate appearances. remains out of a position

Ronny Mauricio, SS/2B/3B:
legitimate offensive weapon

José Butto, RHP
seems destined for a bullpen role.
As a spot starter, the 25-year-old pitched decently

Luisangel Acuña, SS/2B
Mets’ best prospect,
will be an above-average big leaguer because of his power-speed combination

Joey Lucchesi, LHP
performed well as a depth starter
will have a minor-league option left
arbitration-eligible

Bryce Montes de Oca, RHP
6-foot-7
can hit 102 mph
holds minor-league options
missed all of 2023 because of Tommy John surgery.

DJ Stewart, OF
might be worth keeping on the roster as outfield depth
provides a bit of pop from left side
would be arbitration-eligible.

Daniel Vogelbach, DH:
The veteran left-handed batter ended up with a .742 OPS (104 OPS+).
inconsistent
well-liked by his peers in the clubhouse

Luis Guillorme, INF
gifted defender but continues to battle injuries.

New York Giants Fan Rants & Analysis

NY Mets Fan Rants & Analysis

Movie Reviews

TV Show Reactions

Funny Stories

Subscribe to the Giant Mess Podcast YouTube channel

ABOUT NEAL LYNCH:

Irish-Italian-American who graduated from a Catholic high school (even though I’m not Catholic), and a college known for producing doctors and lacrosse players, then became neither. 

Former 4th string quarterback and middle relief pitcher at a Division III university. 

Degrees in Film & Media Studies and Communications.

Worked for Condé Nast, New York Post, SportsNet New York, and Hearst Television.

Divorced dad who blogs, podcasts, writes, edits, optimizes, strategizes, and over-analyzes.  

ABOUT “GIANT MESS”:

“Giant Mess” is a weird sports and entertainment comedy podcast hosted by a giant mess, the Real Cinch Neal Lynch. 

Neal covers New York Giants football, Mets baseball, movies, and TV shows, mixing in funny life stories along the way. 

Episodes focus on movie reviews, tv show recaps, post-game analysis, predictions, reactions, and funny stories about parenting.

Follow me on:


Discover more from Neal Lynch

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

MOST RECENT STORIES